This is the 9th installment in this series. You can find the other entries by clicking on the Reclamation tag.
I turned 58 about a week ago, which means 40 years ago I was splitting my days between senior year of high school and being a regular pioneer, the term Jehovah’s Witnesses gave to members who pledged to spend 1,000 a year in the preaching work. (I also had a job but thought of that as the way to make the other stuff possible.)
I got good grades but was an indifferent student if I’m honest. Public school mostly came easy to me. I loved to read and participate in class and that went a long way toward getting good grades. The classes I tended to struggle in (by which I mean B’s instead of A’s) were the ones that required practice with something unfamiliar. These were the classes I most enjoyed, like Architectural Drawing and French. Neither one of those things came naturally to me, and I didn’t really value struggling with something to get good at it yet. I’ve never felt comfortable making pictures out of anything but words, and it’s only been in recent years, after reacquainting myself with French and then expanding into Spanish, small doses of Portuguese, Italian, Catalan, and currently Romanian, that I find reading other Romance languages easier to pick up than I once did.
I’ve often wondered how the Brians from other, alternate universes approached school, how I might have approached learning if I hadn’t been convinced that learning about this world didn’t matter because it wasn’t going to be around much longer. Current me is legitimately interested in so many different fields that it’s impossible to predict where I might have wound up had I come from people who thought differently about what the future could hold.
But beyond family, the school I attended also had a way of suggesting what the future might hold for us. This was the late 80’s, the end of Reagan’s second term when New Orleans was dealing with the long term effects of cheap oil ravaging the local economy—oil prices have to be on the higher side for it to be profitable to drill in the Gulf of Mexico—and also with a massive increase in drug-related crime. One side effect of the federal government increasing drug interdiction in Florida (aka Miami Vice) was that drug smugglers came through New Orleans instead. By the early 90’s, New Orleans was the murder capital of the country.
The junior high and high schools I attended were on the working class side of Slidell, the New Orleans suburb I moved to in 5th grade and stayed in until shortly after graduation, which is where most of this poem takes place. We lived in a trailer park mostly populated by retirees—my sister and I were the only kids there most of the time—just across the canal from a small subdivision named “Park Place” which was separated from the Black neighborhood by streets that circled back on themselves and a six-foot chain link fence blocking the place where it made sense for a street to connect. Don’t want people walking through, after all, not in either direction. Cousin Street (pronounced COO-zann) was lined with cheap houses and rental duplexes up past Possum Hollow Park until you got to Sgt. Alfred Drive, which served as a main street of sorts: take a right and you see the police station, the fire department, First United Methodist Church; go left a few blocks and you run into St Tammany Junior High. Go a couple of miles past where it links up with Pontchartrain Drive and you’ll pass Salmen High and hit the lake.
Slidell was pretty segregated then, not officially but still, there were black neighborhoods and white ones. I lived in a border area of sorts. The folks who lived in Park Place were mostly white, but on Cousin, you had a mix of poor white and black folks. And between us and the junior high was one of the black neighborhoods. I walked or rode my bike through there to go to school, saw expensive houses beside decaying ones, Cadillacs parked in driveways behind gates and beaters that may or may not start on any given day on the street. And the student body at St Tammany Junior High also reflected that.
I went to school at a time when the overriding theme was that if you wanted to be able to get a job and support yourself, you needed a high school diploma. We hadn’t made the shift to needing a college degree yet, though that was going to happen soon. The dividing line was between having and not-having that diploma, at least for us. Now if you went to college, you could get a good job, a better job, and make real money, but you could do okay so long as you got the diploma. So a lot of our education was aimed at that goal. Get the kids to a diploma.
It may feel a bit like I’m being critical here, but I’m not. Even though I pay my bills teaching college students how to write about their special knowledge in ways non-specialists can understand, and even though my job would be much less in demand if fewer students attended college every year, I think our citizens of our country would be stronger if we didn’t collectively look at the Bachelor’s degree as the entry point into financial stability and created more paths for people who aren’t interested in college.
I’ve gotten sidetracked from what I’d planned to talk about here, forgive me, it’s not like there are easy solutions to any of these many problems in education and I’m not sure I have any good ones to offer. I’m just thinking about what got left out of my particular education and some of the reasons why.
This section of my poem is centered around the Frost line “until we found out that it was ourselves,” and I remember thinking about that line and specifically about my experiences in history and civics classes in junior high and high school and how limited they were. These were classes I did well in because the tests rewarded a sharp memory and the ability to learn from basic narratives, and the narratives were really, really basic. They had to be in order for the teachers to have any chance of covering the subject matter in the limited time they had with 30 restless teens in an under-ventilated room.
Most of the classes I took in this vein all blur together except for one, and that’s because the teacher didn’t stick to the script. Often, this is considered a good thing. It was not in this case, because this is where I first heard the term “the war of Northern Aggression” to refer to the Civil War. She was the teacher who casually claimed that the quality of the lives of enslaved people went down after the Civil War because slaveowners were no longer responsible for their care, but only for their pay, and that the country would be in better shape if the war had never happened, if the Confederacy had been allowed to pursue the future it wanted. This teacher also gave me a copy of The Ayes of Texas by Daniel da Cruz, a truly terrible book which imagined Texas seceding from a libbed-up United States in an attempt to face down the Communist Soviet Union. Some years later I found myself wondering if the main character in this book, Gwilliam Forte, was modeled on Ross Perot or if Perot modeled his political character on Forte. Mind you, all this took place in the context of a Civics class, a one-semester course about how government and citizenship works. Not a history class. We also spent a week learning about the evils of communism using some 1950-60’s era propaganda booklets she’d saved from a closet and guarded carefully because she would never be able to get any more of them. You could make the argument that she was at least covering the subject of the class there.
She stands out because she was so off the rails, but in retrospect, what was arguably more damaging to my education was the lack of anything substantial in my history classes. When that teacher claimed that the Civil War was started by the North over states rights, I didn’t have any reason to disbelieve her because my textbooks and other teachers had kind of glossed over that. It was presented more like the war was inevitable and then it happened and then slaves were free and carpetbaggers were corrupt and reconstruction ended and onto the next section. Why would any student dig deeper into this when they’re being told there’s little of importance there to dig into? It wasn’t until I was well into adulthood that I learned enough to challenge any of those just-so stories even though they’re flimsy as hell at a glance.
I feel like by the time my eldest was going through this part of her high school life that things had improved. They must have because otherwise why would there be so much desire by white supremacists to return history lessons to “America is great, we never did anything wrong, rah rah rah” now.
The poem doesn’t stay in that place throughout, though. I also get into the ways I and my fellow students worked out what it meant to be a teenager and an almost-adult in a world that still valued physical violence. When I think about how many of my fellow white Gen Xers and the younger Boomers have talked nonstop for decades now about how kids these days aren’t tough enough, I think this is where it comes from in part. We used violence to work out our standing among each other and teachers and principals used it to try to keep us in our places and it mostly didn’t work.
Many of my fellow Gen Xers will claim that it made them able to survive and prepared them for the tough times; I saw this a lot during the early days of the pandemic. But even if it were true—and it mostly wasn’t—surviving isn’t thriving. Surviving is enough, and it’s better than the alternative, but it’s not ideal. I look at my eldest and the hard stuff she had to overcome in her life and am glad that whatever else, I didn’t add physical violence against her to the pile, and the same for my almost-tweens now.
Speaking of them, during our time in Romania, I’ve had to become their teacher until we can get them into a private school, and we’re reading a book on archaeology together as part of it. The book doesn’t get into a ton of detail which means we do some research together for greater context, and I’ll also add stuff that I’ve picked up along the way. Some of that involves talking about the ways people have been horrible to each other for stupid reasons, and how some of the people who’ve done the most horrible things were probably our ancestors. But we never talk about feeling guilty for it; just about how it happened and what we can do to try to keep it from happening again.
Here’s section 9 of Reclamation.
We never cared to learn because no one
ever cared to teach us. The list of things
this could apply to is long as Saturday
mornings preaching door to door in August,
hot, yes, but also the first drear days
after school's return, when petty arguments
spouted fists and trips to see the principal,
his paddle worn smooth from years of use.
Until we found out that it was ourselves
we learned from, how to take licks and give
back enough to say we'd held our own
and not be laughed at to our faces.
We pretended they said important things
and they pretended we were listening,
and later on we heard the holes inside
their lectures, what they weren't saying.
Thanks as always for reading. If you’re enjoying the work I post here, please share it with people you know. I also enjoy engaging with you in the comment section, and if there’s ever anything you’d like to ask or talk about that’s not public, you can reach me via email at briankspears-at-gmail-dot-com.